Is the M4 Air a viable replacement for the iPad?

Hello everyone,

I am seeking advice on what will likely be my final Apple purchase for the next five years, as it will ensure that all my devices continue receiving software updates over this timeframe. As a student on a somewhat tight budget, I currently own a Mac Mini M4 (16GB RAM, 256GB storage) gifted to me at Christmas and an iPad Mini 6th gen (256GB, 5G) paired with an Apple Pencil 2. I use these devices for schoolwork, but I anticipate needing CAD software in three years, at which point I plan to purchase a Windows machine. For now, I’m focused on consolidating my workflow and believe that a MacBook Air (16GB RAM, 256GB storage) would suit my needs, but I’d appreciate some additional perspectives.

Initially, I relied on the iPad as a replacement for a school-issued Chromebook, which worked out well. The addition of the Apple Pencil transformed it into an effective digital notepad. I enjoy taking digital notes and am curious about how well I can utilize the MacBook’s trackpad for note-taking. However, I have accumulated a substantial amount of stationery over time.

I feel that paper notes may facilitate communication with my teachers better than digital notes, as I prefer not to draw attention with my elaborate digital setup. Additionally, staring at my iPad for about seven hours a day raises concerns about my eyesight. Another consideration is the potential overlap with my Mac Mini, which I don’t intend to sell since it was a gift. I plan to sell the iPad to a family member for $350.

I’m contemplating the practicality of having two M4 Macs. The new MacBook could run on a power adapter instead of relying on its battery when stationary, drive the same 27” 4K monitor as the Mini, and offer a quality built-in keyboard, unlike my current, less reliable one. I can afford the price difference, especially with educational pricing and by selling the free AirPods I received. Before making a decision, I want to ensure that choosing the M4 Air is the right move and that my plan makes sense.

Thank you for any insights you can provide!